PUF partner interactions at a conserved interface shape the RNA-binding landscape and cell fate in Caenorhabditis elegans.

Protein-RNA regulatory networks underpin much of biology. C. elegans FBF-2, a PUF-RNA-binding protein, binds over 1,000 RNAs to govern stem cells and differentiation. FBF-2 interacts with multiple protein partners via a key tyrosine, Y479. Here, we investigate the in vivo significance of partnerships using a Y479A mutant. Occupancy of the Y479A mutant protein increases or decreases at specific sites across the transcriptome, varying with RNAs. Germline development also changes in a specific fashion: Y479A abolishes one FBF-2 function-the sperm-to-oocyte cell fate switch. Y479A's effects on the regulation of one mRNA, gld-1, are critical to this fate change, though other network changes are also important. FBF-2 switches from repression to activation of gld-1 RNA, likely by distinct FBF-2 partnerships. The role of RNA-binding protein partnerships in governing RNA regulatory networks will likely extend broadly, as such partnerships pervade RNA controls in virtually all metazoan tissues and species.

LST-1 is a bifunctional regulator that feeds back on Notch-dependent transcription to regulate C. elegans germline stem cells.

Notch signaling regulates stem cells across animal phylogeny. C. elegans Notch signaling activates transcription of two genes, lst-1 and sygl-1, that encode potent regulators of germline stem cells. The LST-1 protein regulates stem cells in two distinct ways: It promotes self-renewal posttranscriptionally and also restricts self-renewal by a poorly understood mechanism. Its self-renewal promoting activity resides in its N-terminal region, while its self-renewal restricting activity resides in its C-terminal region and requires the Zn finger. Here, we report that LST-1 limits self-renewal by down-regulating Notch-dependent transcription. We detect LST-1 in the nucleus, in addition to its previously known cytoplasmic localization. LST-1 lowers nascent transcript levels at both lst-1 and sygl-1 loci but not at let-858, a Notch-independent locus. LST-1 also lowers levels of two key components of the Notch activation complex, the LAG-1 DNA binding protein and Notch intracellular domain (NICD). Genetically, an LST-1 Zn finger mutant increases Notch signaling strength in both gain- and loss-of-function GLP-1/Notch receptor mutants. Biochemically, LST-1 co-immunoprecipitates with LAG-1 from nematode extracts, suggesting a direct effect. LST-1 is thus a bifunctional regulator that coordinates posttranscriptional and transcriptional mechanisms in a single protein. This LST-1 bifunctionality relies on its bipartite protein architecture and is bolstered by generation of two LST-1 isoforms, one specialized for Notch downregulation. A conserved theme from worms to human is the coupling of PUF-mediated RNA repression together with Notch feedback in the same protein.

Analysis of the C. elegans Germline Stem Cell Pool.

The Caenorhabditis elegans germline is an excellent model for studying the genetic and molecular regulation of stem cell self-renewal and progression of cells from a stem cell state to a differentiated state. The germline tissue is organized in an assembly line with the germline stem cell (GSC) pool at one end and differentiated gametes at the other. A simple mesenchymal niche caps the GSC pool and maintains GSCs in an undifferentiated state by signaling through the conserved Notch pathway. Notch signaling activates transcription of the key GSC regulators lst-1 and sygl-1 proteins in a gradient through the GSC pool. LST-1 and SYGL-1 proteins work with PUF RNA regulators in a self-renewal hub to maintain the GSC pool. In this chapter, we present methods for characterizing the C. elegans GSC pool and early stages of germ cell differentiation. The methods include examination of germlines in living and fixed worms, cell cycle analysis, and analysis of markers. We also discuss assays to separate mutant phenotypes that affect the stem cell vs. differentiation decision from those that affect germ cell processes more generally.

The in vivo functional significance of PUF hub partnerships in C. elegans germline stem cells.

PUF RNA-binding proteins are conserved stem cell regulators. Four PUF proteins govern self-renewal of Caenorhabditis elegans germline stem cells together with two intrinsically disordered proteins, LST-1 and SYGL-1. Based on yeast two-hybrid results, we previously proposed a composite self-renewal hub in the stem cell regulatory network, with eight PUF partnerships and extensive redundancy. Here, we investigate LST-1-PUF and SYGL-1-PUF partnerships and their molecular activities in their natural context - nematode stem cells. We confirm LST-1-PUF partnerships and their specificity to self-renewal PUFs by co-immunoprecipitation and show that an LST-1(AmBm) mutant defective for PUF-interacting motifs does not complex with PUFs in nematodes. LST-1(AmBm) is used to explore the in vivo functional significance of the LST-1-PUF partnership. Tethered LST-1 requires this partnership to repress expression of a reporter RNA, and LST-1 requires the partnership to co-immunoprecipitate with NTL-1/Not1 of the CCR4-NOT complex. We suggest that the partnership provides multiple molecular interactions that work together to form an effector complex on PUF target RNAs in vivo. Comparison of LST-1-PUF and Nanos-Pumilio reveals fundamental molecular differences, making LST-1-PUF a distinct paradigm for PUF partnerships.

Functional significance of PUF partnerships in C. elegans germline stem cells.

PUF RNA-binding proteins are conserved stem cell regulators. Four PUF proteins govern self-renewal of C. elegans germline stem cells together with two intrinsically disordered proteins, LST-1 and SYGL-1. Based on yeast two-hybrid results, we proposed a composite self-renewal hub in the stem cell regulatory network, with eight PUF partnerships and extensive redundancy. Here, we investigate LST-1-PUF and SYGL-1-PUF partnerships and their molecular activities in their natural context - nematode stem cells. We confirm LST-1-PUF partnerships and their specificity to self-renewal PUFs by co-immunoprecipitation and show that an LST-1(A m B m ) mutant defective for PUF-interacting motifs does not complex with PUFs in nematodes. LST-1(A m B m ) is used to explore the functional significance of the LST-1-PUF partnership. Tethered LST-1 requires the partnership to repress expression of a reporter RNA, and LST-1 requires the partnership to co-immunoprecipitate with NTL-1/Not1 of the CCR4-NOT complex. We suggest that the partnership provides multiple molecular interactions that work together to form an effector complex on PUF target RNAs. Comparison of PUF-LST-1 and Pumilio-Nanos reveals fundamental molecular differences, making PUF-LST-1 a distinct paradigm for PUF partnerships. Summary statement: Partnerships between PUF RNA-binding proteins and intrinsically disordered proteins are essential for stem cell maintenance and RNA repression.

Image-Based Single-Molecule Analysis of Notch-Dependent Transcription in Its Natural Context.

Notch signaling is crucial to animal development and homeostasis. Notch triggers the transcription of its target genes, which produce diverse outcomes depending on context. The high resolution and spatially precise assessment of Notch-dependent transcription is essential for understanding how Notch operates normally in its native context in vivo and how Notch defects lead to pathogenesis. Here we present biological and computational methods to assess Notch-dependent transcriptional activation in stem cells within their niche, focusing on germline stem cells in the nematode Caenorhabditis elegans. Specifically, we describe visualization of single RNAs in fixed gonads using single-molecule RNA fluorescence in situ hybridization (smFISH), live imaging of transcriptional bursting in the intact organism using the MS2 system, and custom-made MATLAB codes, implementing new image processing algorithms to capture the spatiotemporal patterns of Notch-dependent transcriptional activation. These methods allow a powerful analysis of in vivo transcriptional activation and its dynamics in a whole tissue. Our methods can be adapted to essentially any tissue or cell type for any transcript.

Notch-dependent DNA cis-regulatory elements and their dose-dependent control of C. elegans stem cell self-renewal.

A long-standing biological question is how DNA cis-regulatory elements shape transcriptional patterns during metazoan development. Reporter constructs, cell culture assays and computational modeling have made major contributions to answering this question, but analysis of elements in their natural context is an important complement. Here, we mutate Notch-dependent LAG-1 binding sites (LBSs) in the endogenous Caenorhabditis elegans sygl-1 gene, which encodes a key stem cell regulator, and analyze the consequences on sygl-1 expression (nascent transcripts, mRNA, protein) and stem cell maintenance. Mutation of one LBS in a three-element cluster approximately halved both expression and stem cell pool size, whereas mutation of two LBSs essentially abolished them. Heterozygous LBS mutant clusters provided intermediate values. Our results lead to two major conclusions. First, both LBS number and configuration impact cluster activity: LBSs act additively in trans and synergistically in cis. Second, the SYGL-1 gradient promotes self-renewal above its functional threshold and triggers differentiation below the threshold. Our approach of coupling CRISPR/Cas9 LBS mutations with effects on both molecular and biological readouts establishes a powerful model for in vivo analyses of DNA cis-regulatory elements.

The great small organisms of developmental genetics: Caenorhabditis elegans and Drosophila melanogaster.

Experimental embryologists working at the turn of the 19th century suggested fundamental mechanisms of development, such as localized cytoplasmic determinants and tissue induction. However, the molecular basis underlying these processes proved intractable for a long time, despite concerted efforts in many developmental systems to isolate factors with a biological role. That road block was overcome by combining developmental biology with genetics. This powerful approach used unbiased genome-wide screens to isolate mutants with developmental defects and to thereby identify genes encoding key determinants and regulatory pathways that govern development. Two small invertebrates were the pioneers: the fruit fly Drosophila melanogaster and the nematode Caenorhabditis elegans. Their modes of development differ in many ways, but the two together led the way to unraveling the molecular mechanisms of many fundamental developmental processes. The discovery of the grand homologies between key players in development throughout the animal kingdom underscored the usefulness of studying these small invertebrate models for animal development and even human disease. We describe developmental genetics in Drosophila and C. elegans up to the rise of genomics at the beginning of the 21st Century. Finally, we discuss themes that emerge from the histories of such distinct organisms and prospects of this approach for the future.

A sensitized genetic screen to identify regulators of Caenorhabditis elegans germline stem cells.

GLP-1/Notch signaling and a downstream RNA regulatory network maintain germline stem cells in Caenorhabditis elegans. In mutants lacking the GLP-1 receptor, all germline stem cells enter the meiotic cell cycle precociously and differentiate into sperm. This dramatic germline stem cell defect is called the "Glp" phenotype. The lst-1 and sygl-1 genes are direct targets of Notch transcriptional activation and functionally redundant. Whereas single lst-1 and sygl-1 mutants are fertile, lst-1 sygl-1 double mutants are sterile with a Glp phenotype. We set out to identify genes that function redundantly with either lst-1 or sygl-1 to maintain germline stem cells. To this end, we conducted forward genetic screens for mutants with a Glp phenotype in genetic backgrounds lacking functional copies of either lst-1 or sygl-1. The screens generated 9 glp-1 alleles, 2 lst-1 alleles, and 1 allele of pole-1, which encodes the catalytic subunit of DNA polymerase ε. Three glp-1 alleles reside in Ankyrin repeats not previously mutated. pole-1 single mutants have a low penetrance Glp phenotype that is enhanced by loss of sygl-1. Thus, the screen uncovered 1 locus that interacts genetically with sygl-1 and generated useful mutations for further studies of germline stem cell regulation.

Non-autonomous regulation of germline stem cell proliferation by somatic MPK-1/MAPK activity in C. elegans.

Extracellular-signal-regulated kinase (ERK)/mitogen-activated protein kinase (MAPK) is a major positive regulator of cell proliferation, which is often upregulated in cancer. However, few studies have addressed ERK/MAPK regulation of proliferation within a complete organism. The Caenorhabditis elegans ERK/MAPK ortholog MPK-1 is best known for its control of somatic organogenesis and germline differentiation, but it also stimulates germline stem cell proliferation. Here, we show that the germline-specific MPK-1B isoform promotes germline differentiation but has no apparent role in germline stem cell proliferation. By contrast, the soma-specific MPK-1A isoform promotes germline stem cell proliferation non-autonomously. Indeed, MPK-1A functions in the intestine or somatic gonad to promote germline proliferation independent of its other known roles. We propose that a non-autonomous role of ERK/MAPK in stem cell proliferation may be conserved across species and various tissue types, with major clinical implications for cancer and other diseases.

An improved in vivo tethering assay with single molecule FISH reveals that a nematode Nanos enhances reporter expression and mRNA stability.

Robust methods are critical for testing the in vivo regulatory mechanism of RNA binding proteins. Here we report improvement of a protein-mRNA tethering assay to probe the function of an RNA binding protein in its natural context within the C. elegans adult germline. The assay relies on a dual reporter expressing two mRNAs from a single promoter and resolved by trans-splicing. The gfp reporter 3'UTR harbors functional binding elements for λN22 peptide, while the mCherry reporter 3'UTR carries mutated nonfunctional elements. This strategy enables internally controlled quantitation of reporter protein by immunofluorescence and mRNA by smFISH. To test the new system, we analyzed a C. elegans Nanos protein, NOS-3, which serves as a post-transcriptional regulator of germ cell fate. Unexpectedly, tethered NOS-3 enhanced reporter expression. We confirmed this enhancement activity with a second reporter engineered at an endogenous germline gene. NOS-3 enhancement of reporter expression was associated with its amino-terminal intrinsically disordered region, not its carboxy-terminal zinc fingers. RNA quantitation revealed that tethered NOS-3 enhances stability of the reporter mRNA. We suggest that this direct NOS-3 enhancement activity may explain a paradox: Classically Nanos proteins are expected to repress RNA, but nos-3 had been found to promote gld-1 expression, an effect that could be direct. Regardless, the new dual reporter dramatically improves in situ quantitation of reporter expression after RNA binding protein tethering to determine its molecular mechanism in a multicellular tissue.

C. elegans germ granules require both assembly and localized regulators for mRNA repression.

Cytoplasmic RNA-protein (RNP) granules have diverse biophysical properties, from liquid to solid, and play enigmatic roles in RNA metabolism. Nematode P granules are paradigmatic liquid droplet granules and central to germ cell development. Here we analyze a key P granule scaffolding protein, PGL-1, to investigate the functional relationship between P granule assembly and function. Using a protein-RNA tethering assay, we find that reporter mRNA expression is repressed when recruited to PGL-1. We determine the crystal structure of the PGL-1 N-terminal region to 1.5 Å, discover its dimerization, and identify key residues at the dimer interface. Mutations of those interface residues prevent P granule assembly in vivo, de-repress PGL-1 tethered mRNA, and reduce fertility. Therefore, PGL-1 dimerization lies at the heart of both P granule assembly and function. Finally, we identify the P granule-associated Argonaute WAGO-1 as crucial for repression of PGL-1 tethered mRNA. We conclude that P granule function requires both assembly and localized regulators.

Two classes of active transcription sites and their roles in developmental regulation.

The expression of genes encoding powerful developmental regulators is exquisitely controlled, often at multiple levels. Here, we investigate developmental expression of three conserved genes, Caenorhabditis elegans mpk-1, lag-1, and lag-3/sel-8, which encode homologs of ERK/MAPK and core components of the Notch-dependent transcription complex, respectively. We use single-molecule FISH (smFISH) and MATLAB to visualize and quantify nuclear nascent transcripts and cytoplasmic mRNAs as a function of position along the germline developmental axis. Using differentially labeled probes, one spanning an exceptionally long first intron and the other spanning exons, we identify two classes of active transcription sites (ATS). The iATS class, for "incomplete" ATS, harbors only partial nascent transcripts; the cATS class, for "complete" ATS, harbors full-length nascent transcripts. Remarkably, the frequencies of iATS and cATS are patterned along the germline axis. For example, most mpk-1 ATS are iATS in hermaphrodite germline stem cells, but most are cATS in differentiating stem cell daughters. Thus, mpk-1 ATS class frequencies switch in a graded manner as stem cell daughters begin differentiation. Importantly, the patterns of ATS class frequency are gene-, stage-, and sex-specific, and cATS frequency strongly correlates with transcriptional output. Although the molecular mechanism underlying ATS classes is not understood, their primary difference is the extent of transcriptional progression. To generate only partial nascent transcripts in iATS, progression must be slowed, paused, or aborted midway through the gene. We propose that regulation of ATS class can be a critical mode of developmental gene regulation.

A PUF Hub Drives Self-Renewal in Caenorhabditis elegans Germline Stem Cells.

Stem cell regulation relies on extrinsic signaling from a niche plus intrinsic factors that respond and drive self-renewal within stem cells. A priori, loss of niche signaling and loss of the intrinsic self-renewal factors might be expected to have equivalent stem cell defects. Yet this simple prediction has not been borne out for most stem cells, including Caenorhabditis elegans germline stem cells (GSCs). The central regulators of C. elegans GSCs include extrinsically acting GLP-1/Notch signaling from the niche; intrinsically acting RNA-binding proteins in the PUF family, termed FBF-1 and FBF-2 (collectively FBF); and intrinsically acting PUF partner proteins that are direct Notch targets. Abrogation of either GLP-1/Notch signaling or its targets yields an earlier and more severe GSC defect than loss of FBF-1 and FBF-2, suggesting that additional intrinsic regulators must exist. Here, we report that those missing regulators are two additional PUF proteins, PUF-3 and PUF-11 Remarkably, an fbf-1fbf-2 ; puf-3puf-11 quadruple null mutant has a GSC defect virtually identical to that of a glp-1/Notch null mutant. PUF-3 and PUF-11 both affect GSC maintenance, both are expressed in GSCs, and epistasis experiments place them at the same position as FBF within the network. Therefore, action of PUF-3 and PUF-11 explains the milder GSC defect in fbf-1fbf-2 mutants. We conclude that a "PUF hub," comprising four PUF proteins and two PUF partners, constitutes the intrinsic self-renewal node of the C. elegans GSC RNA regulatory network. Discovery of this hub underscores the significance of PUF RNA-binding proteins as key regulators of stem cell maintenance.

The molecular basis of LST-1 self-renewal activity and its control of stem cell pool size.

PUF RNA-binding proteins have diverse roles in animal development, with a broadly conserved role in stem cells. Two paradigmatic PUF proteins, FBF-1 and FBF-2, promote both self-renewal and differentiation in the C. elegans germline. The LST-1 protein is a pivotal regulator of self-renewal and is oncogenic when mis-expressed. Here, we demonstrate that LST-1 self-renewal activity resides within a predicted disordered region that harbors two KXXL motifs. We find that the KXXL motifs mediate the binding of LST-1 to FBF, and that point mutations of these motifs abrogate LST-1 self-renewal activity. The LST-1-FBF partnership is therefore crucial to stem cell maintenance and is a key element in the FBF regulatory network. A distinct region within LST-1 determines its spatial expression and size of the GSC pool. Most importantly, the molecular understanding of how an IDR-rich protein works in an essential partnership with a conserved stem cell regulator and RNA-binding protein suggests broad new avenues for combinatorial control.

Dynamics of Notch-Dependent Transcriptional Bursting in Its Native Context.

Transcription is well known to be inherently stochastic and episodic, but the regulation of transcriptional dynamics is not well understood. Here, we analyze how Notch signaling modulates transcriptional bursting during animal development. Our focus is Notch regulation of transcription in germline stem cells of the nematode C. elegans. Using the MS2 system to visualize nascent transcripts and live imaging to record dynamics, we analyze bursting as a function of position within the intact animal. We find that Notch-dependent transcriptional activation is indeed "bursty"; that wild-type Notch modulates burst duration (ON-time) rather than duration of pauses between bursts (OFF-time) or mean burst intensity; and that a mutant Notch receptor, which is compromised for assembly into the Notch transcription factor complex, primarily modifies burst size (duration × intensity). These analyses thus visualize the effect of a canonical signaling pathway on metazoan transcriptional bursting in its native context.

Sexual dimorphism of niche architecture and regulation of the Caenorhabditis elegans germline stem cell pool.

Stem cell maintenance by niche signaling is a common theme across phylogeny. In the Caenorhabditis elegans gonad, the broad outlines of germline stem cell (GSC) regulation are the same for both sexes: GLP-1/Notch signaling from the mesenchymal distal tip cell niche maintains GSCs in the distal gonad of both sexes and does so via two key stem cell regulators, SYGL-1 and LST-1. Yet most recent analyses of niche signaling and GSC regulation have focused on XX hermaphrodites, an essentially female sex making sperm in larvae and oocytes in adults. Here we focus on GSC regulation in XO males. Sexual dimorphism of niche architecture, reported previously, suggested that the molecular responses to niche signaling or numbers of GSCs might also be sexually distinct. Remarkably, this is not the case. This work extends our understanding of the sexually dimorphic niche architecture, but also demonstrates that the dimorphic niches drive a similar molecular response and maintain a similar number of GSCs in their stem cell pools.